The Bottom Line
One of the best porterhouse cuts I have had in New York.
Pros
- Incredible service
- Cigar Bar attached for after dinner smoke - Heaven!
Cons
- Hidden on the first floor of the Race Palace in Plainview
Description
- Maxwell and Dunne's Steakhouse is located at 1600 Round Swamp Road in Plainview;
- Phone: (516) 694-6200
- Hours: Monday through Friday Noon to Midnight, Saturday 4 p.m. to 1 a.m.
- Serves lunch and dinner;
- Online reservations available;
Guide Review - Maxwell and Dunne's Steakhouse
This place has a gorgeous cigar lounge and a huge bar with a "beautiful crowd" scene. Upstairs is gambler's paradise too - It's like being in Chicago in the 20's. The place looks so good you might almost think it's another steakhouse with a gimmick but it's not. This is the real deal. I've been eating steak for the better part of 15 years and this place is up there with anything else you can think of. It's an art deco masterpiece of a building, the food is incredible and the staff knows their stuff. I've been there a few times with friends and after dinner we stay for a couple hours more at the bar and in the cigar lounge. This is truly a night out to remember. I feel comfortable recommending the most seasoned of steak lovers to Maxwell and Dunne's.
