The Bottom Line
Pros
- Terrific food with great presentation
- Great place to meet people
- Excellent service
- DJ and dancing on specific evenings
- Offers incredibly discounted meals on specific days
Cons
- Not a quiet restaurant
Description
- The Babylon Carriage House address: 21 Fire Island Avenue, Babylon Village
- Phone: (631) 422-5161. Reservations are highly recommended at this popular eatery.
- Cuisine: Seafood, Steak, Pasta
- Average tab per dinner entree: $28
- Hours: Mondays-Wednesdays: 4-10 p.m., Thursdays: 4-11 p.m., Fridays: 4-11:30 p.m., Saturdays: 4-11:30 p.m.
- Babylon Carriage House website
- More information on seafood restaurants on Long Island
Guide Review - Babylon Carriage House Restaurant Review
Contemporary ceiling chandeliers hang next to the original beams. Flickering candles glow on each table. Call in advance to reserve one of the tables next to the fireplace on the second floor for a view of the entire restaurant.
My husband and I loved the food here. We both had the Gorgonzola chopped salad with red onions and a wine vinaigrette. We also sampled the unique "Italian Popcorn," -- a crispy fried gnocchi appetizer with parmesan cheese and a marinara sauce dip.
My Crispy Almond Crusted Sea Scallops were sweet and succulent, and came with a tasty butternut squash puree and shaved fennel and apples for a delectable mix of flavors and textures. My husband polished off an entire one-and-a-half pound lobster, stuffed with crab meat and with sides of whipped potatoes and sauteed spinach.
For dessert, we ordered the decadent Valrhona Chocolate Souffle, and we were not disappointed. The sugary dessert comes with a tasty scoop of pistachio gelato.
For budget-minded visitors: Lobster Bake Wednesdays, 4-10 p.m., feature a steamed one-and-a-half pound lobster, clams, mussels, corn and roasted potatoes for only $19.95 per person. Thursday nights, Shrimp Feast! offers a jumbo shrimp entree, salad and dessert for only $18.95.
Friday nights from 10:30p.m. to 2 a.m., you can dance to hip hop, reggae and party music, and Saturdays from 10 p.m. to 2 a.m., there’s classic dance music for guests 23 and over.

