1. Home
  2. Cities & Towns
  3. Long Island, NY

Cakes on Long Island

- Where to Buy Cakes on Long Island

By Linda Tagliaferro, About.com

Need a cake for your wedding, birthday party or other festive occasion? Whether you're interested in a regular angel food cake or a specialty cake like a wedding cake with many tiers, there are lots of places where you can buy cakes on Long Island. Here's a sampling of places where you can order great cakes on Long Island.

Marneycakes, Inc.

cakes on Long IslandPhoto © Marneycakes
Marneycakes, Inc.
Oceanside location
(917) 499-2744
Marneycakes email

Need a made-to-order cake? Marney creates custom cakes with the best ingredients. There's no artificial coloring or flavors in any of her creations. Each cake is made fresh, so advance booking is highly recommended. Marneycakes also offers birthday cake concierge services, where they'll call your two weeks before your annual events and will deliver the cake to your door. Also specializing in gluten-free, dairy-free and vegan cakes.

Madame Butterfly Cakes - A Custom Cake Shop

Madame Butterfly Cakes
22 Fire Island Avenue
Babylon Village
(631) 669-1069

In the market for a one-of-a-kind cake? Then come to Madame Butterfly Cakes for a unique creation just for your event. From castle-styled wedding cakes to birthday cakes in the shape of lighthouses, Madame Butterfly Cakes can craft something special just for you. Dietary restrictions like egg free, dairy free, nut free and vegan cakes can be made upon request. It's best to order wedding cakes six months in advance, but smaller party cakes can be ordered 3 to 6 weeks ahead of time.

The Chocolate Duck

The Chocolate Duck
310 Main Street
Farmingdale
(516)249-0887

The Chocolate Duck specializes in chocolate molds, cake molds, lollypop molds and many other chocolate and cake supplies. They also offer cake decorating, wedding cake making, candy making and other classes for beginners and advanced students.For a special cake for any occasion, contact the Chocolate Duck's award-winning cake designer, Christina Bisbee.

Cakes by Jay

Cakes by Jay
244 Glen Cove Avenue, Suite H
Glen Cove
(516) 674-8115
Cakes by Jay email

For artistic cakes on Long Island, Cakes by Jay offers stunning wedding cakes and more. These unique cakes were featured on the Food Network's Edible Ornament Challenge and Mystery Client Challenge.

Alpine Pastry Shop

Alpine Pastry Shop
59 route 111 (Hillside Village Center)
Smithtown
(631) 265-5610

From birthday cakes to anniversaries, photo cakes, doll cakes, wedding cakes and more, Alpine Pastry Shop creates specialty cakes for every occasion. You can even customize the size of your cake and pick a tasty cake filling like Bavarian cream, Italian custard, cassata cream, pineapple, blackberry and many more.

Explore Long Island, NY

About.com Special Features

On the National Mall in Washington, DC

Take a look at the capital's best sight-seeing spot. More >

Oktoberfest in Phoenix

Find the best places to celebrate and join the festivities. More >

  1. Home
  2. Cities & Towns
  3. Long Island, NY
  4. Shopping & Services
  5. Long Island Cakes - Where to Buy Cakes on Long Island>

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.