1. Cities & Towns

Discuss in my forum

Readers Respond: Tell us all about your favorite Long Island seafood restaurant

Responses: 10

By , About.com Guide

I've written about 10 great seafood restaurants on Long Island, NY, but there are undoubtedly many others. Tell us which seafood restaurants you think are the best on the Island. Share Your Opinion

Bigelows bonanza

As a former New Englander now in Philadelphia I often crave real fried clams, Ipswitch clams and Bigelows on Long Island offers the best I've ever tasted outside of Maine. Worth the rather long drive from Philly to find a place that does it well. No ambiance, booth and counter seating, but they get the clams shipped in daily and their food can't be beat.
—judycatch22

#1 The new Patio in Free Port !

Great food, plates are Wow, completely deferent from everything else in the area. More like hip Miami hot spot then a Freeport fish house. My wife enjoyed the tuna, house pickled ginger a nice touch. I loved the skirt stake, it was Huge! I would also like to note that the Restaurant is very celiac friendly and the Chef is very accommodating .
—Guest Oscar

favorite seafood restaurant

My family and I love The Fishery in East Rockaway. Always very consistent and fresh. Great menu.
—Guest lori

customer

Fisherman's Catch in Point Lookout, freshest fish right off thier own fleet, can't beat that.
—Guest Jill Moore

hern

I've eaten at Rachels too. I love the shrimp wontons and the crispy calamair and mussels
—Guest hern Nethermahn

Rachels Waterside Grill

My favorite seafood restaurant is Rachels Waterside Grill on the Nautical Mile in Freeport....I've been going there for years and they just got voted Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island by the Long Island Press
—Guest Ed Heslin

Best Seafood Restaurant

The Old Mill Inn in Mattituck is an exceptional restaurant, a must try.
—Guest Brady

Nautlilus Cafe in Freeport

Excellent food and service. Valet parking. Specials besides regular menu. Been a customer for over 10 years and always had an excellent meal and service.
—linesup

best seafood restaurant on li

H20. Best crabcakes anywhere. great wine dinner on wednesday nights
—jennawriter

seafood rest

Southside in Lindenhurst is absolutely the best! Great quality & great food.
—Guest Veronica

Share Your Opinion

Tell us all about your favorite Long Island seafood restaurant

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.